Why? Andrew Bird's Bowl of Fire (Ft. Andrew Bird)

Why? Why'd you do that?
You shouldn't have done that
If I told you once, I told you three times
That you'll get your punishment when you
Show me your crimes
It's not a spell or a curse you put on me
Or the way you make me smile so tenderly
But how I wish it was your temper you were throwing
Damn you for being so easygoing

I thought that time would tell
My sins would provoke you to raise
Raise some hell
No
Not a chance
Whatever happened to fiery romance?
Oh how I wish it was your dishes you were throwing
Damn you for being so easygoing

Why? Why'd you do that?
Why'd I do what now?
Nothing
Forget it
Why'd you do it?
Nothing